vor 9 Monaten
Summary Twenty One Capital, backed by Tether and SoftBank, came public via SPAC merger but has since plummeted by nearly 30% since deal closure. XXI was launched with a Bitcoin-denominated capital structure, emphasizing Bitcoin Per Share (BPS) and Bitcoin Return Rate (BRR) as core metrics. CEO Jack Mallers, a prominent Bitcoin maximalist, has aimed to align XXI's performance and shareholder value with Bitcoin rather than fiat benchmarks. In light of the BPS pivot, I see no reason to buy XXI shares until something resembling an actual business plan is shared with the public. In late April 2025, Twenty One Capital ( XXI ) announced a proposed combination with SPAC entity Cantor Equity Partners, Inc. (CEP). Backed by stablecoin giant Tether and Softbank Group ( SFTBY ), Twenty One Capital was created to be yet another Bitcoin ( BTC-USD ) DAT focused on growing BTC holdings through Bitcoin-related business models. It has not gone well, to say the least. XXI Daily Chart 1/27/26 (TrendSpider) After exploding nearly 500% in the immediate sessions following Twenty One Capital's announced SPAC merger, the stock has fallen by over 85% in nearly a straight line over the last nine months. Furthermore, since beginning trading as XXI in December, the stock is already down almost 30%. Essentially, almost every shareholder who has purchased XXI since the merger is likely underwater. For those watching from the sidelines, could this selloff have created an opportunity in XXI? Twenty One KPIs and Operations Twenty One Capital Homepage 6/1/25 (xxi.money via archive.org) When Twenty One initially launched, the company was quite adamant that 'Bitcoin Per Share' was one of the primary ways to view the business's success. The metric was literally front and center on the company's website. This is what it said in its introductory press release : As part of its launch, Twenty One will introduce two key performance metrics, to reflect its Bitcoin-denominated capital structure and Bitcoin-focused mindset. Those two KPIs were BPS, or Bitcoin Per Share, and BRR, or Bitcoin Return Rate. Fully diluted BPS was expected to grow over time with BRR reflecting the growth rate of BPS. This is what that same website looks like today: Twenty One Capital Homepage 1/27/26 (xxi.money) More recently, the company has seemingly abandoned BPS entirely. Which would relegate BRR as essentially useless as well. Thus, there is not currently a suggested metric by which to measure Twenty One's performance. And this probably shouldn't be all that surprising since the company doesn't appear to have any operating business whatsoever. Twenty One Capital's co-founder and CEO is notable Bitcoin maximalist Jack Mallers. Through the years, Mallers has been a frequent guest on Bitcoin podcasts and an influential speaker at Bitcoin conferences. From my vantage, Mallers has a reputation as being outspoken, possibly even to a fault, as he generally does not mince words or hold back his opinions. I personally see him as a bit of a Michael Saylor-type figure within the Bitcoin community. Though unlike Saylor, Mallers has contributed to the Bitcoin ecosystem through a functioning business via his other company. Jack Mallers is also the founder and CEO of the peer-to-peer Bitcoin Lightning Network-based payments company Strike, which by itself can potentially raise concerns about Mallers' focus on XXI. Though to be clear, I don't personally have that concern about what will essentially be two different Bitcoin-based financial services businesses. On one of Mallers' recent podcast streams, he was asked about the lack of an announced business segment for XXI and reiterated that the company is working on developing a revenue stream and will provide those details when it can. Bitcoin Holdings and Share Breakdown Despite the lack of anything resembling a tangible business, Twenty One is the third largest corporate holder of Bitcoin on the planet after Strategy ( MSTR ) and MARA Holdings ( MARA ). Twenty One reportedly holds 43,514 BTC. This Bitcoin was raised through several different methods. First, Tether and Bitfinex contributed 31,500 BTC prior to the merger closing. Twenty One was also active in raising hundreds of millions in capital through 1% convertible notes due in 2030 as well as through PIPE financing deals. As of January 2nd, there are 346.5 million shares outstanding, and the capitalization breakdown shakes out as follows: Equity Capitalization Summary Shares % Twenty One Class A members 304.9 88.0% Public Shareholders 9.5 2.7% Sponsor 4.3 1.3% Equity PIPE Investors 27.9 8.0% Source: Twenty One, S-1, shares in millions As has typically been the case from what I've seen with these kinds of deals, the carryover shareholders from the original SPAC equity make up a very small percentage of the total outstanding shares. More importantly, Tether and Bitfinex combine to own more than half the outstanding shares, which means Twenty One is a "controlled company" per NYSE rules. mNAV Calculation XXI Common outstanding 1/2/26 346,548,153 Share Price $8.50 Market Capitalization $2,945,659,301 Bitcoin Valuation $3,877,097,400 Basic mNAV* 0.76 Diluted mNAV* 0.84 Source: Twenty One, S-1, analyst's calculation based on $89.1k BTC price For the diluted mNAV estimate, I used the 35 million shares on offer from the company's recently filed S-1. The company has $486.5 million in non-current liabilities, which are due to Twenty One's convertible notes. But even when assuming that dilution, XXI trades at an mNAV of just 0.84. We've seen the compression of mNAVs in the DAT space continue to be a problem in recent months. While an mNAV under 1 takes away the incentive for management to dilute shareholders to acquire more coins, it does force these companies to generate shareholder value through the execution of an actual business strategy. And right now, Twenty One doesn't have one yet. At least not one that is being shared publicly. Risks While XXI might seem like a decent lotto ticket 'buy' at a 16% discount to diluted mNAV, there are certainly still risks to consider. The first of which, Twenty One, is essentially just a Bitcoin holding company as currently constructed. Thus, it will likely have the kind of volatility that we've come to expect from DAT stocks over the last year. While it is a holding company of an asset that is designed to be held in self-custody, Twenty One does utilize a third party for custodial services. Which introduces third-party risk to the stock in the event of a broader crypto market meltdown. Additionally, Tether and Bitfinex own more than 50% of XXI voting power collectively. Meaning retail common stock shareholders have no power as a voting block. As a controlled company, Twenty One can exempt itself from an independent majority on the Board of Directors. Which may not necessarily be a good thing for minority shareholders. Finally, if you're not bullish on Bitcoin as a base case, there's essentially no reason to be long XXI shares today. But there are numerous alternative ways one can express a bullish Bitcoin thesis without introducing leadership risks from a public company. Closing Summary I don't think I can justify calling XXI a 'buy' until we have an actual business plan. Based on the limited filings the market has from the company so far, it appears as though the early operational focus for Twenty One will include Bitcoin accumulation and Bitcoin content generation. Accumulating BTC at an mNAV discount likely isn't happening. And the content generation angle doesn't seem all that lucrative from where I sit. Per the December 12th 10-Q : Twenty One plans to create and monetize high-quality educational content through channels such as subscriptions, licensing fees for enterprises, and sponsored partnerships, which are expected to contribute to its revenue streams. This type of business is not a good enough reason to buy XXI shares in my view. Content generation is already a very crowded area, especially within the Bitcoin community. And given the company's quick pivot from BPS as a KPI to no longer seeing it as an important measuring stick, it seems to me that Twenty One is still trying to figure out what it actually is. I don't know that I'd be selling under $9 per share. But it's tough to be interested in yet another Bitcoin speculative arb opportunity when the precious metals market is on fire to the degree that it is. Based on the opportunity cost alone, I think XXI is a 'hold.'